Facebook Twitter Instagram
    Latest
    • Thank You
    • 4000. Scenes From A Marriage (1973)
    • 3999. The Pianist (2002)
    • 3998. Philadelphia (1993)
    • 3997. Jeanne Dielman, 23 Quai du Commerce, 1080 Bruxelles (1975)
    • 3996. The Green Mile (1999)
    • 3995. Doctor Zhivago (1965)
    • 3994. Glass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery (2022)
    The Mad Movie Man
    • Home
    • Blog
      • All Posts
      • Best Of The Year
        • Best Of 2015
        • Best Of 2016
        • Best Of 2017
        • Best Of 2018
        • Best Of 2019
        • Best Of 2020
        • Best Of 2021
        • Best Of 2022
      • The Decade In Review
      • Box Office Analysis
      • James Bond
      • Oscars
      • RANKED
      • Star Wars
      • The Big Questions
      • Top 10
      • World Cinema
    • Ratings
      • Top 250
      • Top 100 Foreign Films
      • Bottom 50
      • 0 – 1.9
      • 2 – 3.9
      • 4 – 5.9
      • 6 – 7.9
      • 8 – 10
    • Genres
      • Action
      • Anthology
      • Animation
      • Christmas
      • Comedy
      • Crime
      • Documentary
      • Drama
      • Fantasy
      • Film-Noir
      • History
      • Horror
      • Kids’
      • Musical
      • Psychological
      • Romance
      • Sci-Fi
      • Short
      • Silent
      • Sport
      • Superhero
      • Survival
      • Thriller
      • Western
    • Release Year
      • 2020s
      • 2010s
      • 2000s
      • 1990s
      • 1980s
      • 1970s
      • 1960s
      • 1950s
      • 1940s
      • 1930s
      • 1920s
    • Country
      • Afghanistan
      • Argentina
      • Australia
      • Austria
      • Belgium
      • Brazil
      • Cambodia
      • Canada
      • Chile
      • China
      • Colombia
      • Costa Rica
      • Czechoslovakia
      • Czech Republic
      • Denmark
      • East Timor
      • Faroe Islands
      • Finland
      • France
      • Germany
      • Georgia
      • Greece
      • Hong Kong
      • Hungary
      • Iceland
      • India
      • Indonesia
      • Iran
      • Iraq
      • Ireland
      • Israel
      • Italy
      • Japan
      • Latvia
      • Lebanon
      • Laos
      • Malaysia
      • Mexico
      • New Zealand
      • Nigeria
      • North Korea
      • Norway
      • Paraguay
      • Peru
      • Philippines
      • Poland
      • Romania
      • Russia
      • Saudi Arabia
      • Singapore
      • South Korea
      • South Africa
      • Soviet Union
      • Spain
      • Sweden
      • Switzerland
      • Syria
      • Taiwan
      • Thailand
      • Turkey
      • Uganda
      • United Kingdom
      • United States
      • Uruguay
      • Vietnam
      • Zambia
    • About
    The Mad Movie Man
    You are at:Home»Feature»The Big Questions»Why are Hollywood Remakes So Bad?

    Why are Hollywood Remakes So Bad?

    0
    By The Mad Movie Man on March 10, 2020 Feature, The Big Questions

    An American remake of South Korea’s Best Picture-winning Parasite is reportedly in the works, reigniting the old debate about whether or not these Hollywood remakes are necessary.

    And more often than not, Hollywood takes classics of international cinema and manages to ruin them, turning great stories into stale cashgrabs.

    So, this begs the question, why are Hollywood remakes of foreign films so bad?


    Different Backgrounds

    For a variety of reasons, some stories turn out differently when told by different filmmakers and cultures. Sometimes it’s because of the underlying nature of a story, and sometimes it’s because different studios have different objectives for their film.

    Take the legendary Japanese animation Ghost In The Shell as an example. A film made on the fringes of the Japanese movie world, it didn’t do well at the box office at first, but has picked up a strong following since.

    That’s because of its bold and rule-breaking nature, from its stunning animation style to its transcendent themes, lending it strong blockbuster potential, but more importantly powerful and thought-provoking depth and intensity.

    When Hollywood came to remake the movie, however, it was far more concerned with the film’s blockbuster potential, bringing the film’s sci-fi and action elements to the forefront over its dramatic depth in making the 2017 live-action Ghost In The Shell.

    The remake wasn’t a film from the fringes, it wasn’t made with pure originality and passion, but almost entirely as a cashgrab on a popular existing property. But with watered-down drama and emotion that warranted only a PG-13 rating, the remake offered next to nothing that made the original so great.


    Different Audiences

    The two Ghost In The Shell movies epitomise the issues with Hollywood taking foreign films and using them as little more than cashgrabs. But sometimes, bad Hollywood remakes aren’t the fault of the studios, but rather the audiences.

    A perfect recent example of this is the enormous difference between the ingenious Swedish comedy-drama Force Majeure and its Hollywood counterpart, Downhill.

    Both films tackle the same topics in a similar way, with a darkly comic look at a dysfunctional relationship. On the surface, the pair are perfectly similar, and with great talent behind and in front of the camera in both the Swedish and American versions, there isn’t much reason for such a gulf in class.

    Except, the Swedish film is the epitome of dark Scandinavian humour, with an incredible blend of provocative depth, schadenfreude and genuine laughs. The darkness of its humour is what lends such intensity and intrigue to the story, and what makes Force Majeure so outstanding.

    Downhill, on the other hand, doesn’t have the luxury of using such strikingly dark comedy. Not to say that American audiences can’t handle a bit of dark humour, but released as a mainstream comedy, such a style of comedy would not have sat right with US audiences in the way that it would with the Swedes.

    And as a result, Downhill‘s assessment of the same themes as Force Majeure is entirely tame, and light years away from the way that its Swedish counterpart tells its story.


    The Same Story Again

    Above, we’ve seen how Hollywood remakes can fall apart for not staying true enough to the original film. However, simply following another story to the letter is far from ideal either.

    Another Swedish-American comparison shows the dangers of effectively copying and pasting the same story, just with dialogue in a different language.

    Tomas Alfredson’s acclaimed horror-drama Let The Right One In was remade two years later in the US as Let Me In, but did little to inspire with a story that was almost exactly the same, but without any of the original passion and skill.

    The story of a boy who develops a relationship with a vampire teenage girl, both films use horror as a metaphor for coming-of-age drama, yet one delivers the story with palpable passion, while the other is entirely bland.

    Let The Right One In is the original, and has the raw and personal intimacy that makes the film’s coming-of-age themes so striking.

    Let Me In, on the other hand, is entirely derivative, yet without any of the same emotion or uniqueness as the original film. If you don’t watch the Swedish version before the American one, then that may be less of a problem, yet the film still lacks a certain passion behind the camera – an inevitable problem of telling somebody else’s story.

    Finding a balance between staying true to the original and being completely derivative is far from simple, but it can often be the key to making or breaking a great Hollywood remake.


    Are All Hollywood Remakes Really That Bad?

    It’s easy to bash Hollywood remakes for all sorts of reasons, and often, it’s entirely deserved. But that doesn’t mean all Hollywood remakes are terrible.

    Take Martin Scorsese’s Best Picture-winning The Departed as an example. A thrilling reimagining of Hong Kong’s Infernal Affairs, Scorsese’s film is a perfect balance between understanding the original property and developing its own voice.

    Infernal Affairs is a brilliant Hong Kong gangster film, and Scorsese – more at home in the genre than arguably any other director – stays true to its themes of loyalty and deception.

    The Departed, however, builds on Infernal Affairs with a deeper story that celebrates the ingenuity of the original film, all the while injecting it with a little bit of New York magic. And that makes The Departed a great film in and of its own right, while simultaneously proving an intelligent and faithful remake.

    And that’s the case with so many other Hollywood classics that many of us don’t even know are remakes. Some Like It Hot is a remake of the French Fanfare Of Love, Scent Of A Woman is a remake of the Italian film of the same name. And the list goes on.

    So, while it’s fair to bash Hollywood for its remakes when they go wrong, remember that there are some great ones out there too, many of which not only improve on their foreign counterparts, but become classics in their own right.

    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    The Mad Movie Man
    • Website
    • Facebook
    • Twitter

    The Mad Movie Man, AKA Anthony Cullen, writes articles and reviews about movies and the world of cinema. From January 1st, 2013 to December 31st, 2022, he watched and reviewed a movie every day. This is the blog dedicated to the project: www.madmovieman.com

    Related Posts

    Top 10 Most Anticipated Movies Of 2022

    Top 10 Best Movies Of 2021

    Every James Bond Film RANKED

    Follow Me Online!
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • YouTube
    • Tumblr
    New Releases
    8.2
    December 25, 2022

    3994. Glass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery (2022)

    5.6
    December 10, 2022

    3969. Falling For Christmas (2022)

    6.9
    December 4, 2022

    3956. The People We Hate At The Wedding (2022)

    5.4
    December 3, 2022

    3954. Disenchanted (2022)

    7.4
    December 3, 2022

    3953. Meet Cute (2022)

    7.6
    November 23, 2022

    3934. Do Revenge (2022)

    7.0
    November 18, 2022

    3929. The Wonder (2022)

    6.7
    November 13, 2022

    3924. See How They Run (2022)

    Recommended Movies
    8.3
    Review
    March 13, 20140

    486. Ferris Bueller’s Day Off (1986)

    8.6
    Review
    January 6, 20180

    2007. The Road (2009)

    8.4
    Review
    January 11, 20220

    3613. Apollo 13 (1995)

    8.6
    Review
    September 18, 20190

    2685. Girl Walk // All Day (2011)

    8.8
    Review
    March 30, 20140

    507. My Neighbour Totoro (となりのトトロ) (1988)

    Popular Posts
    December 31, 2022

    Thank You

    8.2
    December 31, 2022

    4000. Scenes From A Marriage (1973)

    7.8
    December 30, 2022

    3999. The Pianist (2002)

    8.2
    December 29, 2022

    3998. Philadelphia (1993)

    7.5
    December 28, 2022

    3997. Jeanne Dielman, 23 Quai du Commerce, 1080 Bruxelles (1975)

    9.1
    December 27, 2022

    3996. The Green Mile (1999)

    7.6
    December 26, 2022

    3995. Doctor Zhivago (1965)

    © 2023 ThemeSphere. Designed by ThemeSphere.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.